The Senate recently passed S.1464, the so-called “Packaging Reduction and Recycling Infrastructure Act.” Behind its friendly title lies a set of sweeping, burdensome, and costly regulations masquerading as environmental reform.

Despite strong opposition from myself and fellow Republicans, the bill passed, and it promises to become yet another crushing mandate on businesses, driving up costs for consumers across the state.

This isn’t just political rhetoric. According to a May 2024 study by The Business Council of New York State, the Act would result in over $1 billion in increased consumer costs within its first five years. That translates to an extra $720 per household per year. From manufacturers sourcing materials to families picking up Friday night takeout, this bill will make everyday life more expensive for all New Yorkers.

Once again, Democratic leaders in Albany claim to champion affordability while pushing policies that make New York less affordable than ever.

The Carton Council, a group representing the four leading manufacturers of food and beverage cartons, warns that this bill could either lead to a wholesale ban on key products or become unenforceable due to its unworkable mandates. Either scenario spells trouble for businesses and consumers alike.

If signed into law, the Act would require businesses to register with a yet-to-be-formed “packaging reduction commission.” This new bureaucracy would enforce rigid timelines for eliminating widely used packaging materials, including plastic straws, single-use utensils, cups, plates, and bags. It even mandates the reuse of packaging for highly perishable foods and beverages—raising serious concerns about food safety and driving costs even higher.

New York once took pride in its entrepreneurial spirit and strong local economies. We’ve long supported local producers and fostered productive business relationships. Policy crafted in Albany should reflect that legacy—with fair, informed input from the industries that call this state home, especially our small businesses, which are the backbone of our communities.

With New York already boasting a 90% recycling rate, this bill is unnecessary overreach. It will raise costs, hurt businesses, and do little to actually improve the environment.